Date and venue: Friday 13 November 2026, Tonhalle, Zurich
Orchestra: Tonhalle-Orchester Zürich
Conductor: Paavo Järvi
Programme: Gustav Mahler, Symphony No. 6 in A minor
My Sixth will pose riddles that only a generation which has absorbed and truly digested my first five symphonies may attempt to solve.
Wanderings
Drifting through this city of Zurich, which I did not know, like a Wanderer, I passed the house where Wagner wrote and composed much of the Ring, a few kilometres from Thomas Mann’s grave at Kilchberg, then the Cabaret Voltaire and its Dada experiments, in the city where Joyce wrote much of Ulysses, and found myself standing in front of the Tonhalle. There was a circus nearby, and it struck me that this kaleidoscopic drift, literary and musical, was in fact the opening of the article I was about to write, so closely does Mahler’s Sixth answer, in its own way, to that aesthetic of building and unbuilding at once.
This symphony is so evocative, so biographical. It stirs memories that belong to each of us alone, and yet it is universal. It is surely Mahler’s most personal symphony, his most intimate, and Alma knew it: no work, she said, had come to him so directly from the heart. We call it the Tragic, but it is also an echo of scraps of a life, of musical fragments, of themes and variations Mahler must once have heard.
Ridges and cutting edges
From the first movement, the Tonhalle orchestra unfolds its implacable momentum in heady, poisonous sonorities, and Paavo Järvi shows how far the tragic works its way into the symphony, by the insinuation of fate and by the demonstrative force of its contrasts. His conducting is always rather technical, but narrative too, plain when it needs to be, sparing of means, perhaps at times a little dry. One should note the attention paid to every desk, from the leader Julia Becker to the percussionists — the true masters of the evening — and down to the xylophone, which clatters like macabre knucklebones. The cowbells offstage, which Mahler himself described as the last earthly sounds rising from the valley to a spirit climbing away towards the summits, let this first movement be read as the tragic, precipitous face of Bruckner’s orchestral masses. Järvi chisels a mountain landscape with its ridges, its peaks and its cutting edges, and here again it is Zurich we find, that cultural geography which catches up with us whether we will or no.
The scherzo as sound object
Paavo Järvi has chosen to place the scherzo second, which is not the order of the premiere in May 1906, when Mahler had already put the Andante second in Essen and never again conducted it any other way. Nor is it the order printed in the score on the desks that evening — Breitkopf’s brand-new critical edition, published this April. The conductor is therefore using the most recent material in existence, but he refuses the order it sets down. And under his baton, precisely, the scherzo becomes less a race towards the abyss than a sound object, a contemplation held slightly at arm’s length.
Studied: that is the word. Every accent, every sforzando is finely executed, and we are — this is what strikes one in this reading — a long way from the emotional breakers that a Bernstein, a Sinopoli and so many others have found in this symphony, sometimes a little cheaply; a long way too from Barbirolli, implacable but slow. Järvi knows how to slow without growing heavy. He makes every tie to life tell, and all the lulls in a movement supposed to be breathless are sculpted. All this might seem a shade too even, too regulated, perhaps because our ear is used to grand drama and to readings that declare themselves tragic, but Järvi’s choice holds its ground. Here is a Mahler who lets the music speak, in an analytical approach that glances now and then towards Pierre Boulez. Järvi still allows himself a certain sensuality: he savours, he sways, he turns greedy in the slow passages, but always with great clarity, a demonstrative clarity. He lets us hear the clarinet’s swagger — too amiable here, perhaps. There is less cataclysm than in other readings, certainly, but the choice will convince anyone who also wants to hear the music, and its structure first.
A Schubertian lullaby
The Andante has great tenderness. Paavo Järvi plays it most lovingly, with a first-rate Philippe Tondre on oboe, in the very hall where Richard Strauss’s Oboe Concerto was premiered in 1946. I kept thinking of a chamber-music approach, a Schubertian one above all. The nickname does not lie: this symphony is tragic as Schubert’s Fourth is, and now and then I caught myself hearing, in this Andante, echoes of the String Quintet in C. One also meets the shimmer of the Adagietto from the Fifth, more luminous perhaps, and inevitably I think of Thomas Mann’s grave, of Venetian landscapes, Canaletto rather than Guardi. The Andante is played as a calm lullaby rather than a tragic song, a gentle melancholy still lit by a few fires. And one falls to thinking about the autobiographical power of this music, its gift for raising passages of our own histories from the dead — memories of mountains, of lakes, of summits. That too is Mahler’s universal subjectivity, and Paavo Järvi draws it out. Already one thinks of the Dolomites of the music to come, of the landscapes of Dobbiaco and their cowbells. Then one is moved, almost without noticing, by a violin glissando, and by Martin Frutiger’s cor anglais, heartbreaking. The close is more majestic, and one is struck by some formidable pianissimi.
The poison garden
As for the finale, I had never noticed that it could be read as a set of variations around Schubert’s Unfinished and its melancholy, resigned theme. Always the percussion, always the finesse; one hears everything, the bells included. Something comes apart, and this in the most tightly built movement Mahler ever wrote, and I have the impression of a collage foreshadowing the parodic finale of the Seventh, which is strange. I find in it moments of wandering, of strolling through a poisonous alpine garden. Here and there, trombone passages open onto the Wagnerian world, Siegfried perhaps, and there I am again in the street where Wagner composed part of his Ring. This movement seems to me beautiful and bizarre at once, heteroclite, in the sense in which Baudelaire wrote that the beautiful is always strange. Mahler’s hero hesitates to pick those poisonous flowers. Then Paavo Järvi accelerates and lets us hear how uneasy this movement can make us, between the jeering brass, the echoes of military marches out of Mahler’s childhood, the faintly martial, brutal accents. Järvi had certainly been saving himself for the end. Always that muffled threat in the high pastures: there is something here of Ramuz’s La Grande Peur dans la montagne. The hammer blows are spectacular — two only, Järvi holding to Mahler’s final wish, who had struck out the third, the one meant to fell the hero “like a tree”, in Alma’s phrase.
This is the ascent, in thinning air, of a walker who can still see a clump of edelweiss in a meadow and who turns away from it. The air runs short, of course, but running short of air is intoxicating too. The sound collages produce an effect of circus, of parody, a kind of derision and mockery aimed at our small human affairs. How hard it is to climb clear of the cow-pastures, how hard to rise towards the ideal with the trivial at one’s heels! The conductor conveys well that alternation of tone between full-blooded passages and the poignant thinning of the oxygen. At every entry of the harp, of the high violins, of the bass drum, we are a little higher, a little further off. Järvi sculpts a soundscape of ascent and of turning inward — that of the walker who watches himself climb and who, at every halt, finds himself crushed by the weight of fate.
On a tight rein
We are far, obviously, from the slow, macabre descent of a Bernstein, or from Abbado’s twilit Mahler at Lucerne, and it is precisely that pathetic twilight that Järvi refuses. One struggles, one fights through to the inexorable conclusion, which wins the orchestra a deserved triumph. The Tonhalle orchestra, perfectly together, technically irreproachable, fields great soloists, great percussionists, winds, oboes, violins of absolute precision, and Paavo Järvi’s conducting declines all pathos in order to let the musical argument be heard — yet, on a tight rein, it lets something through, lets an emotion surface, a just emotion, in a tempo giusto. Here is a Sixth full of taste and intelligence. Such is Paavo Järvi’s Mahler: this refusal of a sentimentality that can turn vulgar or easy, and it is precisely that restraint, that reticence, which lets the music breathe and which uncovers the places where the spirit of Strauss, of Wagner, of Thomas Mann and of Joyce still blows. Places always end up colouring music, just as terroir makes a wine, over and above the skill of the vintner.
Related reading : Mahler at the Concertgebouw — The Chief Conductors Edition · The Energy of Subtlety: Otello at the Wiener Staatsoper