Date and venue: 26 January 2024, Théâtre des Champs-Élysées, Paris
Orchestra: Orchestre national de France
Conductor: Kazuki Yamada
Soloists: Regula Mühlemann, soprano; Matthias Rexroth, countertenor; Ludovic Tézier, baritone; Chœur de Radio France and Maîtrise de Radio France
Programme:
Albert Roussel, Bacchus et Ariane, Suite No. 2, op. 43
Carl Orff, Carmina Burana
The Théâtre des Champs-Élysées, a high place of Parisian concert life which once shook to the echoes of the scandals and the ovations of the Ballets Russes, welcomed the Orchestre National de France on 26 January under Kazuki Yamada, for an evening promising a journey through time and through the emotions. On the programme: Roussel’s Suite No. 2 from Bacchus et Ariane and Carl Orff’s epic Carmina Burana.
Bacchus et Ariane, a less intoxicating nectar than expected
Albert Roussel, though a contemporary of the leading figures of musical impressionism, cut his own wake through the world of composition. His decision, at twenty-five, to abandon a promising naval career for the path of composition speaks of a search for artistic and personal renewal. All his life Roussel sought to reconcile the formal rigour inherited from his classical and Romantic predecessors with the exploration of new harmonic and rhythmic paths. His music, anchored in its time though it is, stands apart by a stylistic independence and a pursuit of originality entirely his own. The ballet Bacchus et Ariane, premiered at the Paris Opera in 1931 with choreography by Serge Lifar, is one of the summits of Roussel’s output – a kind of counterpart to Ravel’s Daphnis, which has since become far more popular.
The score draws us into the legend of Ariadne, abandoned by Theseus and finding love again with Bacchus. The Suite No. 2, by far the more often played – though still rare in the concert hall – is drawn from this ballet and was presented to the public in February 1934. It condenses into a single orchestral piece the dramatic and emotional essence of the myth. It embodies the fusion of Romantic lyricism with an orchestral modernity, and so marks out Roussel’s singularity in the musical landscape of his day.
Yet for all the richness of the orchestration and the shading offered by the Orchestre National de France, this reading did not entirely succeed in arousing the intoxication and the excess such a work calls for. Whether it was the accident of the venue or a projection on my part I cannot say, but the opening of the work took on genuinely Russian accents, Stravinskian, with sonorities by turns muffled and highly coloured – created by the sensuousness of Luc Héry’s solo violin, played with fine intelligence – and at times jerky, in that polyrhythmic manner characteristic of the composer of the Rite. At the same time one noted a certain languor, not to say a certain slowness, now and then distilling moments tinged with boredom. Perhaps it was restraint in the execution, or too insistent a search for balance, that kept Roussel’s music from reaching the height of exaltation and voluptuousness. The technical execution was beyond reproach, reflecting the orchestra’s command and precision under Yamada’s baton, but the always slightly dry acoustic of the Théâtre des Champs-Élysées at times limited the expansion and the resonance of Roussel’s sound palette. That acoustic peculiarity sometimes hindered the work’s capacity to wrap the audience fully in its mythological and emotional world. The rhythmic jolts and the mocking clarinets, not unlike Dukas’s The Sorcerer’s Apprentice, never reached the Dionysian labyrinth promised by this sonic spell, with its oriental colours that a Florent Schmitt would not have disowned. Yamada has craft, undeniably, and he is worth watching as he throws himself about to obtain effects – not always, alas, followed up by the players. Flutes and oboes, happily, knew how to distil fine poetic moments, all sensuous arabesque, between classical rigour and audacity (one thinks of certain lines of Racine – “c’est Vénus tout entière à sa proie attachée”, or “je le vis, je rougis, je pâlis à sa vue” – for an eroticism contained by classical form, which never stops the embers from flaring).
What one awaited above all in this suite was the finale, crowned by a brilliant bacchanal, the work’s high point, in which Bacchus crowns Ariadne with stars stolen from the constellations. This Allegro brillante, in A flat major, is meant to close in an apotheosis of joy and excess, a summit of exaltation. The orchestration, described as dazzling, aims to plunge the listener into the heart of a divine feast, where the grandeur of Bacchus and the triumph of love are painted in vivid orchestral colour and unbridled energy. One imagines easily enough what the work’s first conductor, Pierre Monteux, might have offered the listeners of his day. Here, though, the heady potential of this closing bacchanal seemed considerably reduced. Remarkable as the precision and clarity of the playing were, the expected brilliance and vitality – those musical flames that should set an audience alight – seemed somewhat dimmed, as if the raw energy of the composition had been held in check, not letting the scene unfold with all the dramatic intensity Roussel had in view. The relatively timid applause confirmed this relative disappointment.
Carmina Burana: undeniable vocal power, but an epic breath half asleep
Let us not pretend: the large audience at the Théâtre des Champs-Élysées that evening had come above all for the main event, Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana. Let us go a little further, to understand the risk of disappointment inherent in works of such extreme popularity: who really knows Carmina Burana beyond the opening chorus “O Fortuna”? This cantata, composed between 1935 and 1936, draws on twenty-four poems from a collection of the same name, first published in 1884. Carmina Burana means “Songs of Beuern”, a reference to the Bavarian monastery of Benediktbeuern where the original manuscript was found. The text mixes Latin, Middle High German and Old French, and treats – often with a touch of irony – a variety of secular and timeless themes: the caprices of fate, the fleetingness of existence, the exaltation of spring, and the delights of drink, sensuality, gambling and lust. Carmina Burana also stands out by the scale of forces it requires, an imposing stage complement of some 120 choristers, children and adults, to carry its power and energy. But apart from two very popular moments, the work is seldom played. And indeed, after those first three glorious minutes – whistled along by a few tactless listeners – the work can disconcert, and at times even bore.
The performance set off at a brisk tempo, perhaps a shade too brisk for the dry acoustic of the hall. A more languid approach might have served better the moments of grandeur and of intimacy the score contains. Kazuki Yamada offered a frequently poetic reading with Russian accents: one thought often of the wildness of Mussorgsky’s Night on Bald Mountain. Other influences came to mind now and then: the poetic sweetness of Respighi’s pastel frescoes, set against evocations of a decadent Rome – cruelty, gold and purple – which recall, all proportions kept, Antonin Artaud’s Heliogabalus. It is at times gleaming and brassy, with valiant moments, helped by the physical commitment of a conductor at ease in massive works on this scale. Nonetheless – and this comes back, let us repeat, to the imbalances of the score and to the two moments the audience most awaits – the reading only rarely reached the sublime or raised a transcendent shiver. To grasp the variety of tone and atmosphere in this work, shot through with a knowing second degree, one should not hesitate to turn to Jochum’s recording, which has not aged a day.
The vocal line-up, from very good to excellent, was one of the evening’s strengths. Regula Mühlemann (soprano) shone by her clarity and precision, and by the fine poise of her highest notes at the close. Ludovic Tézier (baritone), with his stage presence, his diction and his remarkable vocal technique, dominated the concert in particular: he had to be heard in his high notes set against the low, in the score’s most deliciously parodic moments. Singing Germont at Bastille at the same time, he found his own space here, embodying with humorous phlegm the figure of a tipsy abbot. Special mention for the tavern scene, which seemed to loosen up choirs and players who had at moments been a little stiff: the unusual choice of giving the aria “Olim lacus colueram” (normally sung in falsetto by a tenor) to a countertenor allowed Matthias Rexroth – the evening’s real star, and the only singer without the score in front of him – to reveal a most welcome theatrical sense, aided by a bassoon as mocking as one could wish. His brief appearance as a despairing swan condemned to the roasting-spit shone by its inventiveness and commitment. On the whole the Chœur de Radio France, uneven though it was, distinguished itself by the richness of its timbres and by its precision. One was taken by “In taberna quando sumus”, that hymn to debauchery, delivered with colour and brilliance. One thought often of Prince Igor, and of the famous “Polovtsian Dances” – that exotic Russian colour which, surprisingly, if a little single-minded, saved the evening and made for a fine occasion right to the end, when the conductor, relaxed, did not hesitate to step down from his podium and conduct from among the players, before the chorus “O Fortuna” rang out once more, carrying off a fairly easy triumph.
Albert Roussel
Bacchus et Ariane, Suite No. 2
Carl Orff
Carmina Burana
Kazuki Yamada, conductor
Orchestre National de France
Regula Mühlemann, soprano
Matthias Rexroth, countertenor
Ludovic Tézier, baritone
Maîtrise de Radio France – Marie-Noëlle Maerten, chorus director
Chœur de Radio France – Martina Batič, chorus director
Broadcast on France Musique: radiofrance.fr