Date and venue: 27 May 2024, Victoria Hall, Geneva
Orchestra: Wiener Symphoniker
Conductor: Petr Popelka
Soloists: Julia Hagen, cello
Programme: Antonín Dvořák, Cello Concerto in B minor, op. 104
Richard Strauss, Don Juan, symphonic poem, op. 20
Richard Strauss, Till Eulenspiegel, symphonic poem, op. 28
Geneva on Viennese time
A fine concert, without a hitch, and a generous set of encores – but a Dvořák and a Strauss that were a shade routine.
It is always a pleasure to attend the concerts put on by the Migros cultural service – excellently run, and a chance to travel and to discover the greatest performers and the finest orchestras.
The evening opened with Dvořák’s Cello Concerto, very well played by Julia Hagen. First performed in London on 19 March 1896, the work was composed in the winter of 1894 and is the Czech composer’s last American work. It reflects Dvořák’s homesickness, three years away from his country, and the vibrant energy of his creative mind.
The first movement, Allegro, owes a great deal to Brahms’s Fourth Symphony. Julia Hagen showed impressive dexterity and total commitment, bringing magnificent dark colours to the woodwind. The music breathes, moving from the sombre to the genial with ease, even if the orchestra – technically impeccable – at times lacked liveliness and seemed somewhat neutral. It is worth noting that the concerto could give the impression of being a symphonie concertante rather than a concerto proper. Everyone listens to everyone; one enjoys the brass and the strings; but the orchestra sometimes hung back. Seen that way, the three movements felt strongly autobiographical, evoking both the composer’s native Bohemia and America, like a theme and variations on Dvořák’s life and on his Ninth Symphony.
The second movement, Adagio ma non troppo, introduces a trio of woodwind – oboe, clarinet, bassoon – with a theme half folk-like, half religious. This movement, a poignant mixture of lament and funeral march, in a climate where majesty and piety meet, allowed Julia Hagen’s musicianship to unfold, with great breadth and some moving moments. She is committed and technically beyond reproach. Petr Popelka was most attentive and careful, with admirable technical command. The third movement, Allegro moderato, is marked by a march rhythm and by a solo part whose virtuosity intensifies, not least in the runs of semiquaver triplets. A tutti follows, its main theme ringing out like a fanfare of strings, and a crescendo brings the work to a close in a powerful orchestral blaze. Unfortunately that final blaze was not triumphant enough tonight. It wanted a certain flame, and a sense of contrast in the colours.
As an encore, Julia Hagen – joined by one of her fellow students from Vienna, the gifted violinist Paula Zarzo – played Lullaby by the composer Rebecca Clarke. A lovely moment of gentleness and complicity between the two musicians.
The second half was given over to two symphonic poems by Richard Strauss, Till Eulenspiegel and Don Juan. Technically irreproachable again, the playing nonetheless lacked depth and relief. Petr Popelka – who bears a passing resemblance to Andris Nelsons – did not quite get the piece off the ground. The orchestra, of a very high standard, lacked colour and contrast. Certain sections, the woodwind especially, offered fine poetic moments, but the whole remained linear and single-minded, at times merely loud, short of the liveliness and mischief that are the essence of Till Eulenspiegel. More than once the music grew noisy without supplying the necessary shading. As Debussy put it, Till Eulenspiegel is “an hour of new music in the madhouse”; tonight the work stayed too serious, far from the lightness and humour it is meant to raise.
Don Juan gave us occasion to salute the orchestra’s remarkable horns. Strauss was twenty-four when he composed this work, now a pillar of the symphonic repertoire. Inspired by Lenau, the symphonic poem explores desire, possession and despair. Don Juan is normally a violent hero, passionate and pleasure-seeking, in quest of an unattainable ideal; aware of the vanity of conquest, he turns bitter and disabused. Don Juan ought to be a brilliant, epic work, full of urges and gratifications, with dynamic contrasts, rhythmic accentuation and vibrant colours. Tonight’s reading did not entirely convince. For all Popelka’s efforts, the work stayed linear, the transitions at times short of fluency and of dynamic contrast. The poetic moments offered by the woodwind were beautiful, but not enough to hold the interest from end to end.
If you want to be stirred by an idiomatic Don Juan, brimming with sap and impulsive fire, go and find Kempe’s famous recording with the Staatskapelle Dresden.
The evening ended with generous encores that carried the audience into the festive atmosphere of a New Year’s concert, with two pieces by Johann Strauss: Frühlingsstimmen and Unter Donner und Blitz. This was by far the best part of the evening. Played without overloading, the pieces had an elegance and a spirit entirely in the Johann Strauss tradition. Here the Wiener Symphoniker showed a naturalness and an animation that had been missing in the Dvořák and the Richard Strauss. It is a repertoire they know by heart, and one that lets the conductor show off the orchestra’s qualities. The playing was virtuosic, colourful and alive. The audience was not deceived, and applauded warmly. Faces were delighted.
So, for all the talent and the musical moments, the evening as a whole remained muted: a technically solid performance, but one that sometimes lacked the contrasted, mischievous vitality of Strauss. The Viennese encores happily brought a festive and animated conclusion, a reminder of the core repertoire of this other orchestra of the Austrian capital.
Read also: Strauss and Dvořák in Chamber Form – the Camerata RCO in Grenoble · Turnage and Vaughan Williams – Daniel Harding and the Orchestre de la Suisse Romande · The Energy of Subtlety: Otello at the Wiener Staatsoper